Talk:Piano Sonata No.5 (Galuppi, Baldassare)
Thanks to Regtien for uploading (and the work involved in transcribing)!
A few comments based on the Michelangeli recording referred to (presumably):
- adagio instead of andante?
- ABM seems to not play the grace notes in bars 4 and 9.
- ending of trills has one more note each in bar 17
- no grace note in 50
- bar 53 has G chord instead of F
- grace note (e appogiatura to d) in 55
- 2 staffs missing(!) between bars 63 and 64
Feel free to delete if already known or taken care of.
Thanks again! - PJ.
Many thanks to D.W.J. Regtien for having typeset this nice piece. Just a comment on the style used: as this is a baroque piece, my guess is that many of the detailed instructions are not present in the original notation. Things like when to play legato/staccato, arpeggio were very likely not present, the same goes for the ">" accents. Did Galuppi even know about "sf"? Echo effects like the mp/p in bars 1/6 or 11/13 were probably not written, as they are standard practice for such music.
I also wonder, if many things set as separate full notes might have been appoggiaturas/acciaccaturas or mordents. I'm especially thinking of the short notes in bars 57 and 58, but this might even be true for the upwards a-b in the main motive in the very first bar and whereever this same motive appears throughout the piece.
But anyway, I have played from these sheets many times, and me and my family enjoyed it very much. Paepse 16:23, 14 July 2010 (UTC)