Talk:Sonata No. 2, Op. 15 (Czerny, Carl)

Entries for this work duplicated - one probably with wrong op. no.

I suppose it's a mistake: but there are two entries under "Czerny" for his 2nd Piano Sonata - one under the title "Piano Sonata No.2, Op.13", and the other under the title "Sonate Nr. 2 op. 15".

The scores for the two appear to be the same size, so quite likely it's the same file; but one is not yet available, but the other is, so I can't check for sure if they are the same.

Also note the differing opus numbers - one is probably incorrect, unless this sonata has two opus numbers.

Just thought I'd mention it, if anyone would like to correct it. M.J.E. 09:10, 20 September 2008 (EDT)

The correct op.number is 13

[New comment - previous one doesn't terminate properly:] Thanks for telling me - the number on the title page is not quite legible, and the second digit could be either a 3 or a 5.
But I was pointing out that the Sonata actually has two separate entries, quite needlessly; I have now seen that the two files are exactly the same. This may just lead people to believe initially that there are two sonatas where in fact there is only one.
For the sake of clarity, and to save storage space on the server, I would think one of the duplicates should be removed. The other sonatas' entries begin with the description "Piano sonata", so perhaps the entry for this sonata that begins with just "Sonata" could be deleted. Whichever one was kept, it could then be amended with the correct opus number if it isn't already correct. M.J.E. 13:44, 1 October 2008 (EDT)
It was because of that confusion that I listed it under opus 15 in the Czerny opus list on en-Wikipedia for a time, actually... Eric 10:12, 9 March 2009 (EDT)