| Anonymous Oboe concerto ⟨User:Tim.willis1685⟩ |
[#7191] |
Have you seen my remark on the workpage of the oboe concerto from the SLUB? Best regards, Notenschreiber.
| Posted at 20:36, 24 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
|
Thank you for letting me know. I did not see your message.
I have just fixed the errors. It seems, every time I fix a mistake, a make a new one, so please let me know if you find anymore. It is very helpful! All the best.
| Posted at 01:29, 25 May 2014 by Tim.willis1685 (administrator) |
| Just realized by accident: In your Graun oboe concerto, 2. movement at end of measure 198 and the beginnung of measure 199 some e flat should be e, in measure 184
the last quarternote should be e flat instead of e, i think. It´s a fine concerto, by the way.
Added: Gottlieb with double t, not Gotlieb.
Posted at 17:11, 25 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator)
Edited at 17:22, 25 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
| I've uploaded a new corrected score and set of parts for Graun G minor. In bar 184 do you mean the E natural in the bass part? It is marked that way in the manuscript part. The other mistakes have been fixed.
| Posted at 05:20, 26 May 2014 by Tim.willis1685 (administrator) |
| Sorry, i was confused about the E natural in bar 184, it´s correct.
| Posted at 20:49, 26 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
| I thought I'd ask your for opinion on something.
I have started uploading the Concerti from Dresden by Anonymous Composers but as I can't add more than one piece with the same name, I am having trouble giving names to them that will properly identify them. There will be several "Violin Concerto in D major" for example, but I don't want to add a number after them; like this "Violin Concerto in D major (2)". This implies that they were written or compiled is some sort of order, which they weren't.
I haven't been able to find other examples of this and so I don't know how problems like this are dealt with.
I had an idea instead to use the Number given on the cover label like so "Violin Concerto in D major, Fach33/Lage46." Or more simply "Violin Concerto (No.46) in D major".
What are your thoughts on this?
P.S I think all Concerti in this collection are compiled in Fach 33, so that information might not be necessary.
| Posted at 04:50, 29 May 2014 by Tim.willis1685 (administrator) |
| I think just to say "Violin Concerto (No.46) in D major" is somehow misleading by the same reasons like "Violin Concerto in D major (2)".
What about using the SLUB sigle "Violin Concerto in D major, Mus.2-O-1,19"? I will ask Davydov about this problem, he is the chief librarian here
of IMSLP
Posted at 06:36, 29 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator)
Edited at 10:45, 29 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
| That's a good question. My view is that the Schrank number should be given in the title, e.g. "Violin Concerto in D minor, Schrank II/33/24 (Anonymous)", which is one of the formulations used by RISM in their catalogues. So it's important to include the Schrank number in the general information section of the workpage as well. I'll move the two works recently uploaded to their new titles, and then you can use that as a guide for the others.
Because of the dispute over whether the cello in Schrank II/33/92 is a solo or continuo part, I'll move it to "Concerto in A minor".
| Posted at 08:35, 29 May 2014 by P.davydov (administrator) |
| I like this solution. (Of course only for "Anonymous").
| Posted at 10:44, 29 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
| Hi Tim, you have very busy with the "Anonymous" concertos! Let me mention one less important detail. The "Schrank II numbers" should not occur in the title under
"general informations", but as opus/catalogue number below. The general policy here is to say it in an example, that a title is "Sonata in C major" not
"Sonata in C major op.1"
Posted at 06:31, 30 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator)
Edited at 06:43, 30 May 2014 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
| Thank you for fixing my uploads for the anonymous works. You may have noticed that I have tried this with some new uploads for Graun, but when I add the GraunWV numbers in the catalogue numbers box, then they are not added to the title. What is the trick for doing this? Or should I just let someone else correct this after I have uploaded the files.
I hope to add some of the schrank II violinsonatas soon (and there are lots of them) so it might be good for me to learn! Best wishes!
| Posted at 15:58, 9 June 2014 by Tim.willis1685 (administrator) |
| |
