| Tagging Marathon tomorrow! ⟨User:Notenschreiber⟩ |
[#11106] |
Hey Volunteer you might want to keep an eye on this page, thanks to Davydov for creating this!:
http://imslp.org/wiki/IMSLP:Tagging/July_2015_Tagathon
Cheers!
| Posted at 22:25, 30 June 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
Hey Notenschreiber, I noticed from your tagging that you are not adding in any spaces between the semi-colons and the tags, can you please go back and space these out? It seems the system accepts it without the spaces but it looks better if they were spaced out.
| Posted at 16:09, 3 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
I changed my last entries accordingly, but i don´t think that this is really important, because it only appears in the edit modus.
| Posted at 16:22, 3 July 2015 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
|
It seems a bit odd that the system accepts this because all the tags that I have seen have the spaces being done like this (psalms ; vv ch orch ; la), Its not that important really, mostly an aesthetics thing as long the system accepts the tags.
| Posted at 16:38, 3 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
Hey Notenschreiber if you tag any works that you don't know the instrumentation, add "und". This way we will come back to these pieces later and try to get the exact instrumentation.
Posted at 14:29, 8 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator)
Edited at 14:29, 8 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
I used this already sometimes. Recently i had an example with a solo flute and some other unknown instruments. But "fl und" does not work.
As instrumentation tag "und" must be the only tag, right?
Posted at 14:32, 8 July 2015 by Notenschreiber (administrator)
Edited at 14:36, 8 July 2015 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
|
We are putting the pieces in the undetermined instrumentation that we have no idea from external sources what the instrumentation might be, say if we only had an arrangement of the whole original pieces, like the massive WIMA files on here. This way we will come back to these later since these will be put into another list, away from the untagged list right now.
| Posted at 14:44, 8 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
We are putting the pieces in the undetermined instrumentation that we have no idea from external sources what the instrumentation might be, say if we only had an arrangement of the whole original pieces, like the massive WIMA files on here. This way we will come back to these later since these will be put into another list, away from the untagged list right now.
But no "und" must not be the only tag, don't forget the Genre and language (if required) too! "Und" is only for instrumentation.
| Posted at 14:45, 8 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
Your explanations do not meet my point. What i want to know is the following: if we have a partial information about the instrumentation, but don´t know all of it, then we can tag "und", because something is unknown. But there seems to be no way to tag the partial information we had. An example: We have a concerto for flute,
but only with "Klavierauszug". So we don´t know if "fl str" or "fl orch" is suitable. Just "und" is poor. "fl und" doesn´t work.
Posted at 14:58, 8 July 2015 by Notenschreiber (administrator)
Edited at 15:41, 8 July 2015 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
|
We would use the "und" if we don't know the precise instrumentation for the whole work. This doesn't affect the Genre or language, which is also still required for the piece. You DON'T use "und" for partial instrumentation, you use it for if you don't know the FULL precise instrumentation at all. If the instrumentation has like a "?" by like orchestra or say piano for example, you would still tag the insturmentation as "und" possibly if you cannot find external sources that explain the instrumentation fully. Something like just "Voices" could be considered "und" like in renaissance pieces because the instrumentation then is not specific enough, but not always.
Is this clearer to you?
Posted at 17:42, 8 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator)
Edited at 17:43, 8 July 2015 by Sallen112 (administrator) |
|
It was clear from the very beginning, but i hoped there is way to use partial information about the instrumentation for the tagging. Perhaps i should ask
Davydov about that issue.
| Posted at 20:43, 8 July 2015 by Notenschreiber (administrator) |
|
