Thread - Filtz Trios

Overview > Main Forums > User Talk > ⟨User:Fynnjamin⟩
Filtz Trios ⟨User:Fynnjamin⟩ [#9520]

Dear Fynnjamin:

Unfortunately, your upload of the Sei Sonate da Camara is on the wrong page. The 6 Trios doesn't have a basso part, and the first trio is in G Major, whereas your upload does have a basso and the first piece is in C Major, and looking at the 1st flute part, the themes are completely different.

I can see the new work in Grove but there is no opus number; the listing is "6 sonata da camera, vc, fl/vn, b (1762 or before)".

In the meantime, I can see that we have a couple of pages of Filtz Trios that should be names "Sonate en Trio" or whatever is on the title page. Grove has the same titles we have on the title pages, so I'm not sure where "Trios" came from.

I'll fix the titles on the existing pages, if you will create a new page for the new work.

Thanks, Becky


Posted at 06:10, 16 January 2015 by Steltz (administrator)

I'm not sure I understand, as these are clearly the same pieces, just in a different order to the manuscript. If you compare the flute parts this is quite obvious (Trio 6 the two treble parts are switched). I suggest that the manuscript version be relegated to the Arrangements and Transcriptions tab, and the page title be moved as per your suggestion - so no need for a new page. cheers Fynn

Posted at 10:01, 16 January 2015 by Fynnjamin

OK, I didn't look at order, I just compared no.1. :-) Let me look again . . . BTW, earliest is supposed to go first, though I'm not sure if there is anyway of ascertaining the date of the manuscript. If it's an autograph manuscript then that goes at the top, but I take it there aren't many of those for Filtz. B

Posted at 13:04, 16 January 2015 by Steltz (administrator)
You must be logged in to reply to this thread.
Retrieved from "http://imslp.org/wiki/Special:WikiForum"