Talk:Fandango, R.146 (Soler, Antonio)

Current scholarship doubts that this work is by Soler. See: It's proper place is certainly here, as it has been long attributed to him, but is it possible to list the composer as "Soler (attributed)" or maybe add a line of "Notes:" to the General Information table? October 2007 Homer.

reading the first bars I am convinced that it is not written by Soler. I have performed his concertos for two organs and it seems to me a different and sometimes not very professional manner of composing.

--Metzner 02:47, 15 July 2008 (EDT)

I was reading again and my doubts are quite bigger than 2008. Soler's conciertos are quite perfect in their structure and have no weaknesses concerning his musical 'craftsmanship' But this Fandango has a lot of mistakes which do not sound very good. My opinion: no work of Soler !! Impossible !

--Metzner 08:47, 17 March 2011 (UTC)