User talk:Sean Michael Salamon

(Redirected from User talk:Sean Salamon)

Five Variations and a Fugue on Russia's National Anthem, Op.3

Hi, you blanked the page above. Do you want the work to be deleted? If you just want to replace the file with another version go here and follow the corresponding link. Hobbypianist 20:13, 26 November 2009 (UTC)

No, I would like the work deleted. Sorry for the confusion. Sean Salamon 06:13, 28 November 2009 (UTC)

Ok, done. Hobbypianist 19:33, 7 December 2009 (UTC)

Titles of Works, Licenses

It is completely un-necessary to include instrumentation in titles as we now have a category walker which enables users to find things by forces required. Also, please review the message below with respect to use of the Creative Commons and other available licenses:

Dear Composer or Copyright Owner,

Welcome to IMSLP/Petrucci Music Library! As a composer or other copyright proprietor, please take time to carefully review the Creative Commons and Performance Restricted licenses including the full licenses in PDF format. Generally speaking, the best version to employ for new works is either the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 or the Performance Restricted Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0. These allow for free downloading of the items you post, yet prohibits anyone who downloads the files from IMSLP from selling the files (on Ebay, for example), or from giving public performances on an explicitly commercial basis, making recordings of the work without written permission in advance from you, the composer and copyright owner. However, if you are affiliated with a performing rights society such as SOCAN (Canada), ASCAP, BMI or SESAC (USA), SACD, SACEM or SEAM (France), SABAM (Belgium), GEMA (Germany), PRS (UK), SGAE (Spain), SIAE (Italy), Artisjus (Hungary), ZAIKS (Poland), IPRS (India), JASRAC (Japan), or any of the myriad of similar agencies present in this Wikipedia listing, please note that at least some of these agencies refuse to honor the Creative Commons licenses. You should therefore seriously consider using one of the several IMSLP Performance Restricted Licenses for any works posted here if you are affiliated with a performance rights society.

For those uploading the first time, please remember choose the menu option "Add Your Own Composition" when uploading your original works (even if they are scans of manuscripts or printouts), "Add Your Own Arrangement" or "(Re)Typeset" when uploading new arrangements, and "Add Your Own Edition" or "(Re)Typeset" when uploading new editions of public domain works. As it is normally assumed that composers and arrangers have edited their own work, please leave the "Editor" field empty unless another person has actually edited your work (in which case their name should be inserted). Note also that the English term "Editor" is not the equivalent of the French editeur or Italian editore. "Editor" refers to the person who reviewed and corrected the piece, while the French and Italian words are closer to the English word "publisher". In the "Publisher" field, please use your own full legal name, as making your scores and sound files available for free download on this site constitutes "publication" under the laws of most countries in the world. (Note that this is done automatically when using the new upload tools). Please do not list your works as "public domain" as it is not legally possible for your works to be fully public domain under the 'moral rights' provisions of many copyright statutes around the world. Composers and other copyright owners should be aware that Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 is very similar to public domain as it allows for the unrestricted copying, performance (live and broadcast) and recording of the work (including explicitly commercial use) at no charge, with no compensation or royalties payable to the composer or copyright owner for such commercial exploitation. Note also that the all of the above licenses are considered to be IRREVOCABLE once a file has been uploaded under the lawful copyright owner's authorization.

PS: As long as you have not actually inserted a particular Creative Commons license in the PDF file itself, you are free to change the license after upload to something more suitable. However, any restrictions under an updated license are only applicable to copies of the files downloaded after the date of amendment. Copies downloaded before amendment date are likely subject to the original license terms, so please choose carefully. Composers are also encouraged to make use of our new template {{NoPerf}}, which automatically places works into a new category - Unperformed Works. To add this template to your pages, simply copy and paste the little template above (curly brackets and all) into the "First Performance" field of the "General Information" section on all work pages.

Best Wishes,


Carolus 03:23, 9 June 2011 (UTC) (IMSLP Copyright Admin)

PS: For additional and more detailed explanation, please visit our Composer Portal page.

  • Thank you for moving the page. Is there any particular reason why you directed me to review the CC licenses or is this just the general run-down for someone who has not contributed in several years? Sean Salamon 03:28, 9 June 2011 (UTC)
Hi, just a general run-down. We have a lot more living composers here now, so we need to make everyone aware of the situation with respect to ASCAP, et al. We are presently having discussions with them (and BMI) about the contemporary composers who upload things here. Carolus 06:18, 9 June 2011 (UTC)

Carl Sagan text?

Hi Sean, Did you happen to obtain permission from the Sagan estate? His work is not public domain in Canada (or anywhere else, for that matter). Thanks, Carolus 01:43, 22 December 2011 (UTC)

No, Carolus. I did not. I determined that the use of his text was fair use due to these reasons:
  • The amount of text I quote is insubstantial-- a mere 59 words total contained in two quotations-- and an extremely small excerpt of its gigantic source, the Cosmos documentary.
  • I do not stand to gain anything commercial from this work, nor is my motivation for using them commercial. In fact, I would argue that my use of them is educational.
  • I present content that is already freely available in a variety of sources online.
  • I give Sagan all due credit.
  • In using these two quotations, I am not competing with Sagan's estate in any way, nor am I negatively affecting the market for or value of the copyrighted work.
  • Perhaps most importantly, I am using the quotations to create something new, rather than just copying them.
However, if IMSLP disagrees, I will of course cooperate with them, whether that means seeking permission from Sagan's estate or removing the piece from the database. Perhaps you would be interested to know that both of these quotations can be found at Wikiquote.com, along with countless other longer ones from the same work, under a fair use rationale. Sean Michael Salamon 02:15, 22 December 2011 (UTC)

Thanks very much. You make a strong case that this would fall under fair use. I'm going to go ahead and approve these with the caveat that we will have to pull them down if (and only if) we get a letter from the Sagan estate disputing this assertion. I recommend you copy and paste the points above to the actual work page as it will help to dispell any doubts on the part of visitors downloading the scores. Carolus 02:30, 22 December 2011 (UTC)

Thanks very much, Carolus. I appreciate it. I will gladly append the above points to the work page. If there's somewhere specific on the page that you prefer, I will put it there. Sean Michael Salamon 02:39, 22 December 2011 (UTC)

Thanks for posting it. I moved it to the "general information" section as it applies to the work itself, not just the uploaded file. That way, if you later elected to orchestrate the accompaniment or otherwise arrange the work, the same argument applies. Regards, Carolus 03:11, 22 December 2011 (UTC)