PDF scanned by Google (Harvard)
||Max Vogrich (1852-1916)
||Schirmer's Library of Musical Classics, Vol.104|
New York: G. Schirmer, 1902. Plate 15961.
||Grand Sonata No.3
||Concert sans Orchestre
|Opus/Catalogue NumberOp./Cat. No.
|I-Catalogue NumberI-Cat. No.
||5 originally, then 3
|Year/Date of CompositionY/D of Comp.
||1836, revised 1853
|Composer Time PeriodComp. Period
||1853 revised restored a scherzo and retitled as Piano Sonata No.3
According to Daverio, there were three versions-
- 5-movement sonata composed June 1836
- Revised version published September 1836 (both scherzos dropped, new finale, retitled Concert sans orchestre)
- Second (also?) and very substantial revision published in (but perhaps undertaken before) 1853, (very considerable revision especially of the first movement); entitled Grande sonate, with the second scherzo of the June 1836 sonata restored (but not the first - see Scherzo, H/K WoO 5,1). According to Daverio, throughout all this only the variations movement (on a theme of Clara Wieck (later Clara Schumann) remained basically untouched throughout all the revisions.) (Daverio: Robert Schumann : Herald of a "New Poetic Age", p.150.)